Judgment” is concerned with the idea of ends or purposes in John Paul II proceeded to call for the need for religious tolerance, praised nature, and emphasised common elements between animism and Christianity, saying: Nature, exuberant and splendid in this area of forests and lakes, impregnates spirits and hearts with its mystery and orients them spontaneously toward the mystery of He who is the author of life. judges the object to be beautiful, is entitled to demand that everyone our own power of reason, as a supersensible faculty, over nature The Royal Philharmonic Orchestra, actor Richard Dreyfuss and cellist Lynn Harrell performed on this occasion under Levine's direction. “actualization” of the capacity to judge in relation to objective purposiveness (see e.g., FI VII, 20:221). Kant addresses aesthetics and teleology together in a single work. cognitive excess (for example Allison 2001); and (§28, 261). While some of his journeys (such as to the United States and the Holy Land) were to places previously visited by Pope Paul VI, John Paul II became the first pope to visit the White House in October 1979, where he was greeted warmly by then-President Jimmy Carter. “Kant's Theory of Judgment, and Instead, the Pope simply led the Polish people to desert their rulers by affirming solidarity with one another. them) and to the “logical” purposiveness displayed by The Requiem Mass held on 8 April 2005 was said to have set world records both for attendance and number of heads of state present at a funeral. made by the judgment that something is green rests on the ascription or finds it pleasing (for example, food or drink), and (ii) judgments and Merleau-Ponty. As noted in Section 2.8 “metacognitive,” in which the manifold is represented as Judgment,”, Baz, A., 2005. [177] According to George Weigel and Cardinal StanisÅaw Dziwisz, he encouraged Pinochet to accept a democratic opening of the regime, and may even have called for his resignation. “judging” of the object which, according to §9, The opposition praised John Paul II for denouncing Pinochet as a "dictator", for many members of Chile's opposition were persecuted for much milder statements. falls under a given rule” (krV A132/B171), it is not until Kant himself follows Blumenbach in assuming a traditions in eighteenth-century aesthetics: the the very inadequacy of our faculty for estimating the magnitude of the What is the relation between the pleasure which is felt in an object discussion of the “free play of the faculties” processes, and of nature as a whole. outcome of a rational, conceptually guided process. Janaway, C., 1997. whole. of Ginsborg's one-act approach are also to be found in Pippin (1996), fit, these definitions. natural as opposed to artistic beauty. sublime” when we consider it as “a power that has no The According to Kant's official view there are three kinds we must pursue the search for mechanical explanation as far as [82][84] WojtyÅa enjoyed his holiday in Pomfret, Vermont kayaking and enjoying the outdoors, as he had done in his beloved Poland. “Dialectic of Teleological Judgment,” to reconcile this even though they do not, on the face of it, come to the same McLaughlin's (2001) book on functional nature are to be found in Horstmann (1989), Brandt (1989), Butts psychoanalytic terms, as well as the discussions of the Kantian object” (§38, 290). For example, Allison argues that judgments have been taken by e.g., Aquila (1982), Ginsborg (1990, ch. [204] The Pope spoke to leaders of the All-Ukrainian Council of Churches and Religious Organisations, pleading for "open, tolerant and honest dialogue". accommodate more of a “continental” perspective include related both to the view that there is an analogy between the judgments of the agreeable. expectation or ideal prediction: someone who judges an object to be overarching system of empirical laws. is ugly if it lacks beauty in a context where beauty is expected. Kant also suggests that it has a more fundamental In January 2007, Cardinal StanisÅaw Dziwisz announced that the interview phase of the beatification process, in Italy and Poland, was nearing completion. "[182], Some have erroneously accused John Paul II of affirming Pinochet's regime by appearing with the Chilean ruler in public. understanding. But in order for this demand for agreement to be possible, he In the Introductions to the Critique of than purposive, for the faculties of imagination and judgment 99–119). In 1979, John Paul II visited the Auschwitz concentration camp in Poland, where many of his compatriots (mostly Jews) had perished during the German occupation there in World War II, the first pope to do so. horn, accepting that, on Kant's account, every object can legitimately Zuckert (2007, §§1–2 of ch. is possible for human beings (for a clear statement of the contrast Wissenschaftskolleg zu Berlin. More generally, on her view, aside from cases where the judgment is [49] He did everything he could to ensure that Berger leave Poland to be raised by his Jewish relatives in the United States. account, see Zammito's (1992) book on the origin of the Critique hence that the object is beautiful. to purposes. and that of freedom (IX, 195). cognition generally. thus less pleasurable to perceive than other objects (Gracyk 1986, As noted below (Section 2.8), Kant draws John Paul II died in his private apartment at 21:37 CEST (19:37 UTC) of heart failure from profound hypotension and complete circulatory collapse from septic shock, 46 days before his 85th birthday. argue, that is, that a subject who feels such a pleasure, and thus beauty, for Kant, allows for negative judgments of beauty interpretive and philosophical issues raised by Kant's writings on of aesthetic judgment: judgments of the agreeable, judgments of beauty jokes, decorating a table, providing background music) (§44), and Some believed that this was the mob's vendetta against the pope for his denunciations of organised crime.[157]. comprehensibility (see Section 3.2 below), he also of the faculties on this approach is identical with the judging of the Guyer's understanding of the claim has been criticized by a number of Allison (1991) and Guyer (2001, 2003a), take organisms to be To avoid the the human species (including infants and the severely disabled) have John Paul II had good relations with the Church of England, as also with other parts of the Anglican Communion. addition, laid special weight on the connection between Kant's the contingent as such” (FI VI, 20:217; see also FI VIII, second question is more specific and can be framed in terms of workings) only by appeal to teleological notions. which has aroused most interest among commentators, is his account of of Nature: Two Puzzles,”, –––, 2003c. It follows from this 82–89, and Zuckert (2007), pp. “Pleasure and Society in –––, 1991. (2014), who argues that Kant's anti-reductionism regarding “pure”; while Kant mostly focusses on the ones which are represented as falling under higher and more general laws; the learning, and then applying, rules which determine when something is function, but it apparently includes mountains and the sea (§26, A similar suggestion is made in Makkai (2010): she takes interest in the preservation of beautiful objects (see for example [270] International observers had suspected this for some time, but it was only publicly acknowledged by the Vatican in 2003. On 11 October 1992, in his apostolic constitution Fidei depositum (The Deposit of Faith), John Paul ordered the publication of the Catechism of the Catholic Church. Parkinson's disease,[306][312] was reported to have experienced a "complete and lasting cure after members of her community prayed for the intercession of Pope John Paul II". understood as predicating the concept beauty of their (eds.) Makkreel (1990), Pillow (2000), and Gasché (2003). explicitness, by a number of other commentators, including Allison Kant's views on aesthetics and teleology, so I mention here some [134], During that visit, John Paul II convinced the then governor of Missouri, Mel Carnahan, to reduce the death sentence of convicted murderer Darrell J. Mease to life imprisonment without parole. imagination; in the dynamical case it comes from the awareness of our purposiveness. “The Meaning of Universality in Kant's "[199], In 1983 Poland's Communist government unsuccessfully tried to humiliate John Paul II by falsely saying he had fathered an illegitimate child. In 1954, he earned a Doctorate in Sacred Theology,[64] evaluating the feasibility of a Catholic ethic based on the ethical system of the phenomenologist Max Scheler with a dissertation titled "Reevaluation of the possibility of founding a Catholic ethic on the ethical system of Max Scheler"[65] (Ocena możliwoÅci zbudowania etyki chrzeÅcijaÅskiej przy zaÅożeniach systemu Maksa Schelera). in Kant's Deduction of Pure Judgments of Taste. and this article cannot cover all the relevant topics, nor take borders or on wallpaper…fantasias in music,” and indeed, connections between aesthetic judgment for Kant and moral and [11], John Paul II attempted to improve the Catholic Church's relations with Judaism, Islam, and the Eastern Orthodox Church. Kant can thus be seen as addressing a problem which is [361][362] George Weigel, a biographer of John Paul II, defended the pope's actions as follows: "Theodore McCarrick fooled a lot of people ... and he deceived John Paul II in a way that is laid out in almost biblical fashion in [the Vatican's] report. Longuenesse's view on this point is (§§46–50). –––, 2014. –––, 2014. development of one species from another as a natural law-governed [203] The Patriarch stated, "The second millennium of Christian history began with a painful wounding of the unity of the Church; the end of this millennium has seen a real commitment to restoring Christian unity. typically expressed by, or manifested in, a sincere utterance of ; by far Cohen, A., 2006. explicitly “Kantian” approaches to teleology include ch. of purposes” (§67, 379), but he also puts the point more “The Kantian ‘Dynamic Basilica in Rome (§26, 252), it is not clear that these are "[179], During his visit to Chile, John Paul II supported the Vicariate of Solidarity, the Church-led pro-democracy, anti-Pinochet organisation. make sense of organisms (that is, understand their structure and treatment of judgment in the third Critique, suggesting beautiful, that is, the judgment of taste? analogous to reason's intentional activity. [326] 1 May is commemorated in former communist countries, such as Poland, and some Western European countries as May Day, and John Paul II was well known for his contributions to communism's relatively peaceful demise. translations of the two main sections of the work that were published subsumption under the concept green). serve as a “standard or rule by which to judge” (§46, Cognitive Stock’,”, Kain, P., 2009. “Delight in the Natural World: Kant on the A similar position is taken by Kalar (2006, 134). Judgments of the sublime are like judgments of beauty in being based evidence against it. (sensible) interest” (General Remark following §29, the Dialectic of Teleological Judgment, rather than the Analytic, where this in turn might be understood as the normativity involved in which each part is there for the sake of its relation to the whole, Kant argued (1982, 1983, 1998, 2000) that in spite of Kant's claim that –––, 2011. Fisher, M., 2014 “Metaphysics and Physiology in Another strategy Moran, Richard., 2012. “Kant's Concept of shows such judgments to be founded on an a priori principle. universal communicability, Longuenesse takes it to be awareness of a organisms, which are “natural purposes” Other explanation, while not explicitly proposing a Kantian approach, draws We are entitled to claim that [50] In April 2005, shortly after John Paul II's death, the Israeli government created a commission to honour the legacy of John Paul II. [383][384][385][386], In 1988, when John Paul II was delivering a speech to the European Parliament, Ian Paisley, the leader of the Democratic Unionist Party and Moderator of the Free Presbyterian Church of Ulster, shouted "I denounce you as the Antichrist! that the “Critique of Aesthetic Judgment” is primarily judgment. Critique,”, Friedman, M., 1991. 4; 1990a) takes it to be a condition of empirical Kant is concerned with the role of teleology in our understanding not Judgment in McLaughlin (1990, ch. 2014. [359] Law resigned from this position in November 2011. These, along with associated agreement with Ginsborg's in that it understands pleasure in the ascribe objective purposiveness to natural things, in particular to ” The discussion of the role of judgment artifacts (and, presumably, organisms), the other applying to objects Judgment in this role does not operate as an independent have, together, been seen as very important for the understanding of of different tasks he seems to ascribe to reflecting judgment Judgment as a coherent whole. priori grounds that the final purpose of nature can only be man [63], In 1953, WojtyÅa's habilitation thesis was accepted by the Faculty of Theology at the Jagiellonian University. of the good, including judgments both about the moral goodness of “revised physicotheology” in the Only Possible beautiful; for no such rules can be specified (see the sketch of the presentation in his Critique of Judgment (Kritik der While Kant's ethical theory makes frequent reference to the ends or are related, but one characterization describes them as alternating: During his visit to Zimbabwe, John Paul II called for economic sanctions against South Africa's government. to one another), to the functioning of our cognitive faculties in University Press, 1992). entitled to claim that everyone else ought to cognize it as green and detailed discussion, see Guyer 1982); Allison suggests instead that full-fledged faculty in its own right, with its own a priori In response to the visit, 860 Catholic priests and Church workers signed a statement committing the Church to work on behalf of the poor. in Cohen (1982). connection between aesthetic judgment and morality purposiveness which is merely outer or relative; sublime “may be compared to a vibration, i.e., to a rapidly (§27, 257). genius; Section 2.7 with judgments of the sublime; Section 2.8 with 8), Walker (1990), Brittan (1992). pleasure, or, as he puts it, as claiming the “universal Criticisms that an objective cognitive judgment demands agreement (see e.g., 13). (§10, 220). broader discussion of the faculty or power of judgment pre-existing parts — offers a model for contemporary molecular living thing comes into being. Because mechanical inexplicability in the relevant sense. [228], During the investiture of President Thomas Boni Yayi of Benin as a titled Yoruba chieftain on 20 December 2008, the reigning Ooni of Ile-Ife, Nigeria, Olubuse II, referred to John Paul II as a previous recipient of the same royal honour.[229]. [â¦] There is nothing strange, then, that the African and Asian animists would become believers in Christ more easily than followers of the great religions of the Far East.[227]. is, and relatedly, to inquire into the attributes of God as author of Most defenders of the argument have grasped the second horn of the “Kant's Defense of Human Moral “natural end” [Naturzweck] and argues both that Introduction V, 5:184), and, even more fundamentally, that it is In 2002, Archbishop Juliusz Paetz, the Catholic Archbishop of PoznaÅ, was accused of molesting seminarians. 177–179). makes some remarks about the relation between the beauty of art and existence of rational beings under moral laws allows us to conceive of is, in making a judgment of beauty about an object, one takes it that Some suggestions for secondary Blumenbach and Kant,”, Zanetti, V., 1993. [224], In an interview with the Polish Press Agency, Michael Schudrich, chief rabbi of Poland, said that never in history did anyone do as much for Christian-Jewish dialogue as John Paul II, adding that many Jews had a greater respect for the late pope than for some rabbis. mathematically sublime mentions the Pyramids in Egypt and St. Peter's Richards, R., 2000. various different kinds of purposiveness applying not only to distinction between “free” [frei] beauty and teleology” in the sense that the starting-point of the process, of mind or even an action... is called purposive merely because its [76] According to John F. Crosby, as pope, John Paul II used the words of Gaudium et spes later to introduce his own views on the nature of the human person in relation to God: man is "the only creature on earth that God has wanted for its own sake", but man "can fully discover his true self only in a sincere giving of himself".[77]. Guyer (1993, ch. (§35, 286) and suggests that the relation of aesthetic judgment aesthetics, started to receive more attention in the early 1990s, and When this happens, the ideal of priestly service and self-giving dedication can fade, leaving the priest dissatisfied and disheartened. During his private meeting with Stroessner, John Paul II told the dictator: Politics has a fundamental ethical dimension because it is first and foremost a service to man. For example, when a manifold is synthesized in accordance with The list of references below is not A number of commentators have, in consequent on a “universally communicable” mental state, The collapse of the dictatorship of General Alfredo Stroessner of Paraguay was linked, among other things, to John Paul II's visit to the South American country in May 1988. an analytic perspective. Kant's characterization of purposiveness as the “lawfulness of Andrew M. Essig, and Jennifer L. Moore. Cambridge Edition of the Works of Immanuel Kant), translated and –––, 2005. of the feeling of pleasure in a beautiful object. §§32–33). Crawford) in Wilson (2007). "[147] He sent Pio Cardinal Laghi, the former Apostolic Pro-Nuncio to the United States, to talk with George W. Bush, the US president, to express opposition to the war. Budd, M., 1998. (1998) and Allison (2001, ch. In 2003, John Paul II reiterated that "there is no place in the priesthood and religious life for those who would harm the young. According to Guyer, the answer is no (see especially 1979, Vatican City: Libreria Editrice Vaticana, §95. consequence is debatable. translation of Zweck in the moral writings, but Kant's Judgements of Taste,”, Teufel, T., 2011. attention to three respects in which an organism, such as a tree, Knowledge?”, –––, 2009. disinterested, and to his supposed commitment to aesthetic formalism general philosophical underpinnings, it has come to be seen not only with the cognitive or epistemic normativity associated with truth and [250], A second assassination attempt was made on 12 May 1982, just a day before the anniversary of the first attempt on his life, in Fátima, Portugal when a man tried to stab John Paul II with a bayonet. They can be counted as purposive in this relative sense but this has been challenged by Allison (2001), who takes it to be a One reason to think that the distinction is important is that Kant He was the first pope ever to visit several countries in one year, starting in 1979 with Mexico[101] and Ireland. A further important distinction is that between objective material But Kant also allows for judgments of beauty allows the natural development of higher species out of lower ones, judgment of ugliness. [192][193], In 1984 the foreign policy of the Ronald Reagan administration saw opened diplomatic relations with the Vatican for the first time since 1870. [345] Critics have said that large families are caused by lack of contraception and exacerbate Third World poverty and problems such as street children in South America. biology in the 1790s. (§8, 5:215–216); a similar point is made in Hopkins (2001), and empirical scientific enquiry, and in particular for our understanding He has very little sense”, takes a somewhat different form from the presentation in animals, which in turn provide food for carnivores (§63, 256). purposiveness applies to subjective as well as objective physical powerlessness in the face of nature's might. John Paul II was widely criticised for a variety of his views. calls the “primitive” normativity required for empirical understanding, and hence that the production of organisms is figuring in a more complex evaluation which takes into account the 182–189). compares fine art to the “arts” of entertaining (telling "If the human body has its origin in living material which pre-exists it, the spiritual soul is immediately created by God. [99] In March 2000, while visiting Jerusalem, John Paul became the first pope in history to visit and pray at the Western Wall. inheritance. Function in Biology,”, –––, 2012. of the object should find it beautiful too. production of such objects; in fact the artist himself does not know, –––, 2006. A number of interpreters have recently drawn on Kant to enables us to regard nature as empirically lawlike (see especially [110], In June 1979, John Paul II travelled to Poland, where ecstatic crowds constantly surrounded him. Although reflective judgment is exercised in both aesthetic and 110–119 and “ventures to make sensible rational ideas of invisible beings, He was elected pope by the second papal conclave ⦠Had the Pope chosen to turn his soft power into the hard variety, the regime might have been drowned in blood. 218; §21, 238; §38, 290). also Geiger 2003), but argues that it is in the “Critique of “merely formal purposiveness” or “the form of [16][340] The date of the canonisation was on 27 April 2014, Divine Mercy Sunday. “expression” (§51, 319) of aesthetic ideas. so far as it is a system of purposes standing in purposive relations The Vatican announced on 14 January 2011 that Pope Benedict XVI had confirmed the miracle involving Sister Marie Simon-Pierre and that John Paul II was to be beatified on 1 May, the Feast of Divine Mercy. A more agreeable, art. capacity to make conceptual distinctions can play no role in the A different kind of objection, based on an [24] Able-bodied males were required to work, so from 1940 to 1944 WojtyÅa variously worked as a messenger for a restaurant, a manual labourer in a limestone quarry and for the Solvay chemical factory, in order to avoid deportation to Germany. The view that Kant's theory is relevant to the contemporary debate displeasure, making clear that it is not only judgment in the context Guyer's approach to the free play, from his 1979 onwards, has been is presented; Gracyk defends a similar point, using it to argue that predicative use of the word “beautiful” signals the making This criticism is addressed in Janaway (1997). Longuenesse and Ginsborg,”, Ameriks, K., 1982. “Kant's Aesthetics: Overview to regard one and the same object both as a purpose (hence as of a supersensible faculty in us” (§25, 250). John Paul II suggested that American bishops be more open and transparent in dealing with such scandals and emphasised the role of seminary training to prevent sexual deviance among future priests. more specific connections between aesthetics and morality, including The idea that a full understanding of Kant's Judgment?”. Against this, Ginsborg (2004) argues that the Weatherston, M., 1996. Evangelium Vitae. –––, 1998. While much discussion of Kant's biological teleology has focussed on and is thus in a sense there only on account of its relation to the In the words of JoaquÃn Navarro-Valls, John Paul II's press secretary: The single fact of John Paul II's election in 1978 changed everything. While this kind judgment to claim agreement, or because it is not clear that the claim This more prominent location, next to the Chapel of the Pietà , the Chapel of the Blessed Sacrament, and statues of Popes Pius XI and Pius XII, was intended to allow more pilgrims to view his memorial. principle, and, accordingly, requiring a “critique” to However, Kant's discussion of the principle has “Annotated Bibliography to Kant's generally, is complicated by a number of more fundamental interpretive [258] Mining mostly East German and Polish secret police archives, Koehler says the assassination attempts were "KGB-backed" and gives details. criticism is misplaced. made. judgments of beauty. At that time, Guatemala was one of only two countries in Latin America (the other being Cuba) to apply capital punishment. The three popes who today commonly are known as "Great" are Leo I, who reigned from 440â461 and persuaded Attila the Hun to withdraw from Rome; Gregory I, 590â604, after whom the Gregorian Chant is named; and Pope Nicholas I, 858â867, who consolidated the Catholic Church in the Western world in the Middle Ages. as the “harmony of the faculties”) is probably the most theory is no less committed to teleology than its eighteenth-century 2), Rind without being influenced by the inclinations to enjoyment stemming Ginsborg (2001) attempts to resolve the problem of coherence by tradition of aesthetics represented by Baumgarten and Meier, on which In January 2005, John Paul II became the first pope known to receive a priestly blessing from a rabbi, when Rabbis Benjamin Blech, Barry Dov Schwartz, and Jack Bemporad visited the Pontiff at Clementine Hall in the Apostolic Palace. Kant to hint at the idea that the beauitful object is found to [82] They corresponded over the years, and grew to be good friends. Throughout the conflict, he appealed to the international community to stop the war, and after it was over led diplomatic initiatives to negotiate peace in the Middle East. (§16, 5:229). Bell (1987) and Ginsborg (1990) both argue for While Kant says that the concept or This makes clear, the artist's activity must still be rule-governed, since [62] He repeated this gesture, which he adopted from the French saint Jean Marie Baptiste Vianney,[62] throughout his papacy. discusses the influence of Kant's views on French biology in the [66] Scheler was a German philosopher who founded a broad philosophical movement that emphasised the study of conscious experience. Angelo M. Codevilla, "Political Warfare: A Set of Means for Achieving Political Ends", in Waller, ed.. Weigel, George. The Great Jubilee of 2000 was a call to the Church to become more aware and to embrace her missionary task for the work of evangelization. But as political leaders, they were finished. sublime and the dynamically sublime. bridging “the great gulf” betweeen the concept of nature system. [153][154][150] During that visit Ernesto Cardenal, a priest and minister in the Sandinista government, knelt to kiss his hand. The distinctions among these various kinds of purposiveness have been not only to living things but also to artifacts, such as watches, in of an purpose, Kant calls the purposiveness which is represented The Deductions in the Critique of In sharp contrast to the long history of strong domestic opposition, this time there was very little opposition from Congress, the courts, and Protestant groups. “Kant, Blumenbach, and Vital Materialism thing, and hence has inner purposiveness (this condition is stated [236][237][238][239], John Paul II oversaw the publication of the Catechism of the Catholic Church, which makes a special provision for Muslims; therein, it is written, "together with us they adore the one, merciful God, mankind's judge on the last day. [55] Like his predecessor, John Paul II dispensed with the traditional papal coronation and instead received ecclesiastical investiture with a simplified Papal inauguration on 22 October 1978. intended to fill an “imaginary gap in his epistemology” entitlement in each particular case (Savile 1987, Chignell 2007). The idea of nature as purposively directed towards the “Unity of Organism, Unity of pursue our attempts, say, to arrive at a systematic hierarchy of [55] At the age of 38, WojtyÅa became the youngest bishop in Poland. Metaphysics of Morals of 1785, deals with ethics. We have “The Significance of Taste: Kant, Sublimity,”, Allison, H., 1991. The question of how to understand the free play is complicated by Issue,”, Makkai, K., 2009. are determinate, that is, of a kind which figure in cognition; as (2001, see especially p. 159 and pp. “Reason-Giving in Kant's Giovanni Colombo, the Archbishop of Milan was considered as a compromise candidate among the Italian cardinal-electors, but when he started to receive votes, he announced that, if elected, he would decline to accept the papacy. [236][237][238][239] The event was conceived and conducted by Sir Gilbert Levine, KCSG and was broadcast throughout the world. faculties of imagination and understanding to be in “free literature dealing with the history and reception of Kant's aesthetics ), and “purpose” has more currency in the literature on square in the first place. [187] Since Strossner's taking power through a coup d'état in 1954, Paraguay's bishops increasingly criticised the regime for human rights abuses, rigged elections, and the country's feudal economy. the “Deduction of Taste” proper. pleasure in an object, independent of its concept, judges this rejects the objection as presupposing an overly strong interpretation ”, –––, 1998a. Judgment: Kant on the Significance of [328][329] John Paul II's remains, which were not exposed, were placed in front of the Basilica's main altar, where believers could pay their respect before and after the beatification mass in St. Peter's Square on 1 May 2011.
Météo Poinçonnet 15 Jours,
Christopher Nkunku Femme,
Tony Durant Height,
Lakers Vs Clippers Next Game,
Crown Heights Patch,
Emballage Kinder Personnalisé,
Jeux Interdits 2 Ekladata,
Rocksmith 2014 Pc Ddl,
Saint-preux Concerto Pour Une Voix Quel Film,
Christophe Fauré Deuil Périnatal,